Percy Jackson and the Olympians Fansite

The number one fansite for percy jackson and the olympians

Kevin McKidd, who portrays the Greek God of the Sea, Poseidon was interviewed on Good ...
This is a good one. I appreciate the depth that Chris Columbus shares in each ...
Thursday, February 4th was the date of the premiere for The Lightning Thief. ET has ...
Craig Titley, our beloved screenwriter who adapted The Lightning Thief onscreen, was interviewed by JG-TC.com. ...
The comparison between Harry Potter and Percy Jackson has been everywhere...is "Percy Jackson and The ...
Brandon T Jackson was recently interviewed by ABC The View With The Bay. They included ...
Nintendo announced their video game lineup for most of 2010. Along with many other games, ...
Every movie release makes a big push the week or two before opening day, so ...
Here's a quick update to our recent post for Nintendo's announcement of the upcoming The ...
What's the possibility of a sequel or more? Well, Chris Columbus said that he would ...
 
percy-jackson-tshirt

So I’m sure anyone here where The Lightning Thief has been released has likely seen the movie at least once or has heard of all the changes they made to the film. (And it’s not a few) And now the question is: What do the changes from the books bode for our favorite series??

Well, we here at percyjackson.org have decided to go through the fundamental changes in the film (not the small stuff like Annabeth’s hair color, because I would get Carpal Tunnel Syndrome in my hands before I could finish) and what it could mean for the next four movies. We will work on this until we feel it is complete, so this is the first of several installments of our version of “Changes From The Book”.

rick-chris-craig

Also, I would like to say to all fans: If you’ve seen the movie and hated it because of all the changes from the book, (and a lot of my friends do) and are telling people who have never read the book and never will that it’s a bad movie (and you aren’t saying to them that you think that because of the changes from the book that they’ll never read) PLEASE: say it’s a good movie OTHER than the changes they made.

Why, do you ask? Because it’s a terrific film in it’s own right, minus the changes they made. And for those that will just say that they will rent it on DVD, NO! Because the studios don’t look at DVD rentals, they look at box office results and if there aren’t good box office numbers then they won’t make a second movie, and I know that all of us want to see more films of Percy Jackson. So next time someone asks you if you thought the movie was good, put aside your indignation at the book to film changes, and think of it as a film in it’s own right, and if you can do that and it seems like it would be an entertaining film to anyone asking, tell them to go see it at the local theater as soon as possible! Thank you.

Ok, now let’s get into it.

Change #1: The Big Three Prophecy
In the series the main reason for Percy being born and being attacked at the beginning is because he’s the son of one of the Big Three. (Zeus, Poseidon and Hades) In this case Poseidon. To reset for everyone, in the book, World War II started as a war between Zeus’ and Poseidon’s children against Hades’. Finally, after WWII they made a pact that they would have no more mortal children, which Zeus and Poseidon had broken.

It’s because there was a prophecy made that a child of one of the Big Three, when age 16 would make a decision to save or destroy Olympus. We also learn about Thalia, daughter of Zeus who sacrificed herself to save Grover, Annabeth and Luke. Her tree now guards the Camp.

In the film the reason for Percy not knowing his father, and why not, is because Poseidon was becoming too mortal while being with Sally and Percy. There’s no hint of a prophecy or Thalia, daughter of Zeus, or how Grover, Luke and Annabeth came to the Camp. In the film, Percy is already 17 meaning he’s too old for the prophecy of age 16. They could just make it a prophecy of the kid who is 21 will save or destroy Olympus. Guess we’ll find out.

That is all for now… comment below for your say, be sure to join our mailing list (over there on the right column) to receive updates on our next installment, which is coming soon.






« The Ghost Writer Released….. In Limited Theaters ::: The Lightning Thief Box Office Results Are In Once Again! »
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
  • Stephanie
    I brought my boys to see this movie the weekend it came out, and we loved it! We counted down to the blue-ray release and have watched it so many times already, and continue to love it... then I read the book today. My opinion is that if the movie had stuck with the book, Harry Potter have been blown out of the water! I am terribly sad that Ares was left out as well. What a fun character! If there are future movies (which I am hoping for) there are sure to be a lot of "flashing back" scenes which may get to be a bit much. But regardless, the movie was fabulous, looking forward to more, and hey, movies are never as good as the book anyway... right?
  • Annabeth
    The movie was AWESOME
  • jcchase88
    i agree i liked the movie so much i had to read the books. man i wish i could meet annabeth in real life or just talk to her
  • I agree with this and with all the other comments. I mean, come on, it's a movie! If you want it to be a copy of the book, read the book! Or become a movie director and we'll have a talk after, yeah?

    I am not very scared about the future movies. I trust Chris Columbus very, very much. I think he did not talk about the prophecy because he wanted to keep some good stuff for the future ones... There was no actions about the prophecy in the first book but talking and stories and such. If the movie was overloaded with information that aren't necessary for the moment, the future movies would have been incomplete, and films are usually made for everybody, and even people who did not see the first titles should understand. Motion picture and literature are completely different industries.
    I think Clarisse will show up when she will be needed in the adventure, they won't pay an actress for two scenes anyway, and they don't want to mix up the audience, because they are not all angry fans! Anyway, I don't know if this seems clear, because I'm not really good in explaining what I think... I think that the Lightning Thief, the book, and the movie, are two different things, and both are fantastic. And I was stupidly happy Clarisse and Thalia didn't show up, because I had some tiny innocent hopes about the crew doing public castings. Silly thoughts, since I live in Quebec! (who cares, really)

    Percy Jackson and Chris Colombus are best friend now. Please, don't insult him in front of me. He's my idol since Harry Potter 1. Percy Jackson's fans are the coolest fans of the world!
  • CabinEleven
    I never thought of it that way, but I agree, Chloe! I'll say I definitely liked the book better, and I didn't like how they condensed the movie. I really wish Mr. D and Ares had been in it, since they're both such important characters. But, to each his own. And I can't wait to the Sea of Monsters!!!:)
  • CabinEleven
    lol, i mean see.;)
  • Shelly
    Amen. Well said!
  • Ciara
    Its a small difference but it still matters to me XD In the book percy cant wear the flying shoes that luke gives him because then he would be in Zeus's domain and could die but in the film he wore them.. not grover ... which i kinda wanted to see :(

    but i agree with you the movie was great.. and im not sure but didnt it say BASED on the best selling series.. so i dont think it was actually made to be exactly like the book but then agian i could be remembering wrong : ) but when I saw the movie I was really impressed aside from all the parts they changed and whenever anyone says ''idk if i should see that'' I tell them that it was an awsome movie cuz it was XD

    I think a reason why ppl are complaining is because it was directed by Chris Columbus and were looking forward to how great he would make it because of his previous work on HP 1 AND HP 2
  • Katharine
    Can I just say THANK YOU for what you said at the beginning. I know the film was very different to the book, we all do, but putting that aside it really was a GREAT film and I'm so sick of all the PJO fans that keep ragging on it! With fans like that out there we'll never get our sequels! And for every change they made in the first film, they can fix it all for the next ones.

    The fact that they left out the prophecy was disappointing. It felt like they weren't thinking about potential sequels at all, weren't trying to build a series, but just wanted to make a stand-alone film. Having said that I think they can easily slot the prophecy back into the Sea of Monsters, either as something Chiron has already known about but didn't want to reveal (which is pretty much what happened in the books anyway) or as a prophecy that was just made.

    What I'm more worried about is the lack of Kronos and the Annabeth/Luke/Thalia back story. Not so much the Thalia part actually, I think she too can be easily slotted in to a sequel (along with Clarisse) but the Annabeth/Luke connection which actually ends up being important at the end ... not sure how they can fix that given that they didn't show any kind of connection b/w them at all, and Annabeth fought him at the end without any reservations.

    Not mentioning Kronos as the puppet pulling the strings is a pretty huge omission to. Like a Philosopher's Stone film with no mention of Voldemort - insane. Not entirely sure how they can fix that ...

    Those are the only two things I'm really worried about though, I think everything else will be okay. Let's just hope we actually get those sequels! (And hope that, whether they bring back the same screenwriter or not) that they're a bit more faithful to the books from here on!
  • theskybreaks
    Totally agree. It was a hilarious film to watch in its own right. Sure, they slaughtered the story, but the acting utterly destroys Harry Potter acting ( minus Bellatrix ). So, enjoy it for what it was, because it was enjoyable and encourage your friends to go see it. We all want more movies...I deff want to see Nico get to the big screen.
blog comments powered by Disqus


- Wow! Get PJO Email Updates -

Email:


  • PJO Polls (Take Them All)

    Which PJO book was your favorite?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...



Recent Comments

PercyJackson.org is a fan-run website dedicated to all news, updates, facts, sneak peeks, and events for Percy Jackson, Rick Riordan, The Lightning Thief movie, cast and more. Join in on the fun!

Recent Comments

Logan Lerman Talks with Vanity Fair

On Jan-4-2010
Reported by admin

New York Times Names The Last Olympian

On Dec-11-2009
Reported by Cabin_3

Percy Jackson Official Site Updated

On Dec-29-2009
Reported by Cabin_3

Who Logan Lerman Has Dated

On Jan-3-2010
Reported by admin

How Hot Is Percy Jackson Right Now

On Feb-1-2010
Reported by admin